10. Carlito – 3 Eliminations
Well isn’t that ‘cool’… In 2006, Carlito entered the WWE Championship Elimination Chamber match at New Year’s Resolution against Hall of Famers Shawn Michaels and Kurt Angle, and two future Hall of Famers in John Cena and Kane, as well as his buddy Chris Masters. Very few people would have expected him to eliminate half the field in an impressive showing.
Carlito, a former United States Champion in his own right, entered at number three in the match and would eliminate the ‘Big Red Machine’ with the help of Masters, before single-handedly pinning ‘Mr WrestleMania’. Carlito would then turn his attention to his Masters. This left just Carlito and defending WWE Champion John Cena left in the match. Cena would go on to pin Carlito with a roll-up, ending a good showing for the Puerto Rican.