6 Returns At AEW Double Or Nothing 2025

The annual AEW Double or Nothing pay-per-view takes place on May 25.

Now in its seventh year, this will be the first time the event has taken place outside of its usual home of Las Vegas or Jacksonville, coming live from the Desert Diamond Arena in Arizona.

Double or Nothing has been known for its surprises over the years, including Jon Moxley’s AEW debut at the inaugural PPV, and last year’s show delivered the unannounced return of former world champion MJF.

With the event known for surprises, here are the stars who could make their returns to the company at this year’s show.

6. Eddie Kingston

AEW star Eddie Kingston

Eddie Kingston has been out of action since May 2024 after suffering a serious leg injury in a Last Man Standing match with Gabe Kidd – fracturing his leg and damaging both his ACL and meniscus.

This week, Kingston said he’s not ready to return and won’t be at the pay-per-view, but that hasn’t stopped fans speculating due to how many times in wrestling history comments like that have just been a misdirection.

With Kingston’s long-standing history with Jon Moxley, Claudio Castagnoli, and especially Kidd – as the man who put him on the shelf – his surprise return during Anarchy in the Arena would make perfect sense.

Could we be in for another classic Kingston moment at Double or Nothing – just like in 2022, when a bloodied Kingston made his way to the ring carrying a tank of gasoline?

Click the next page button below for more