WWE
On the December 26 edition of Friday Night SmackDown, Carmelo Hayes defeated Ilja Dragunov to win the United States Championship.
Now that he holds the gold, fans should see Hayes continue the tradition of the US Title Open Challenge.
With his first open challenge on the horizon, there are a plethora of options for potential stars who could step up to the plate for a shot at the title first.
Here are eight potential options for the first Carmelo Hayes WWE US Title Open Challenge.
8. Johnny Gargano

Following his huge victory over Ilja Dragunov to become the new WWE United States Champion, Carmelo Hayes cut a celebratory promo backstage.
However, this interview was interrupted when Johnny Gargano attacked Hayes and told him that he ruined everything.
Gargano is someone who challenged Dragunov for the gold during his reign and could do the same with Melo.
Gargano stepping up to be Hayes’ first challenger would be appropriate and properly follow up from this attack the week prior.
Click the next page button below for more
Trending
- Hardy Boyz Character Change Update
- Two More WWE Stars Qualify For 2026 Elimination Chamber Matches
- Royce Keys WWE Raw Status
- New Mystery Reveal On WWE Raw
- WWE Star Sets World Record With $16 Million Sale
- WWE Star Returns On Raw
- New General Managers For WWE 2K26 MyGM Mode Confirmed
- Former WWE Star Addresses Championship Loss
- First Look At Nick Aldis & Adam Pearce As WWE 2K26 Playable Characters
- WWE Star Forced To Take Time Away Due To Injury
