This world is made up of binary opposites. Light and dark. Day and Night. Good and bad. Big and small. Red and blue. Raw and SmackDown Live.
There is often a debate to be had over which of WWE‘s two flagship shows is better. Over the past year or so, the general consensus has been Raw, with SmackDown Live lacking the same star power and big names at the red brand’s disposal.
However, following last week’s Superstar Shake-up, both rosters received somewhat of a makeover, and it looks as if SmackDown Live might be on the edge of a renaissance and re-establishing itself as the ‘A’ show.
With that said, every Wednesday we are going to bring you an objective and indisputable* comparison over which show was better that week.
*By objective and indisputable, we do of course mean maybe slightly subjective, and possibly a little disputable.
Nonetheless, we are going to split each show into three main areas, the three most important areas that make up the formula of being a great wrestling show; those being the ‘quality of matches’, the ‘storyline progression/pay-per-view build’, and ‘fun’, as we decipher which show was the best this week, Raw or SmackDown?
Quality of Matches
The quality of matches plays an integral part in the making of a good wrestling show, after all, it is a wrestling show. This may be less so for WWE than other promotions, but it is still important to cater to the portion of the audience that appreciate the art form that is professional wrestling.
We’re going to run through each match on each show, give it one or two comments of review, before reaching the overall verdict of which show had the better matches this week.
We will only focus on the matches themselves for now, and not anything that happened immediately before or after them.
Raw
Elias defeated Bobby Roode
This was a pretty slow match, mostly made up of backhand chops and rest holds. WWE even managed to squeeze in a split-screened commercial to promote Greatest Royal Rumble this Friday. The only positive of this match is that the finish came out of nowhere, with Elias picking up the victory via a quick roll-up.
Matt Hardy and Bray Wyatt defeated The Ascension (Konnor & Viktor)
The Ascension managed to get in more offense than I expected, but in the end, it was a pretty convincing win for the ‘Deleters of Worlds’ as they pick up momentum heading into Jeddah where they face the Bar for the WWE Raw Tag Team Championships.
Dolph Ziggler and Drew McIntyre defeated Titus O’Neil and Apollo Crews
This one was a more convincing win than Hardy and Wyatt’s over the Ascension. The match itself was nothing special but established McIntyre and Ziggler as a genuine threat to Raw‘s tag team division.
Chad Gable defeated Jinder Mahal
Mahal attacked Gable during his entrance and dominated this match for the majority, and the crowd was beginning to get restless, as evidenced by “Rusev Day” chants, which I think is the most noise they made all night. Gable managed to escape with the win, albeit with what looked like a botch. Probably Mahal’s fault.
Braun Strowman and Bobby Lashley defeated Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn
Lashley actually took a lot of offense in this one, building to a highly anticipated Braun Strowman ‘hot tag’. Once that happened, Lashley and Strowman gained the upper hand, and following a Stalling Suplex from Lashley, the ‘Monster Among Men’ hit a Running Powerslam on Zayn for a decisive victory. There were a couple of entertaining moments in this match, namely Owens and Zayn trying to run away, but overall, it will probably just serve to add further tension between Owens and Zayn, and Raw General Manager Kurt Angle
Finn Bálor and Seth Rollins defeated The Miztourage (Bo Dallas and Curtis Axel)
Don’t ask why Axel and Dallas are still using The Miz’ music and referring to themselves as the Miztourage, but nonetheless, the match was a lot more even than I thought it would be. Eventually, Bálor and Rollins managed to get the job done, but somewhat irritatingly remained completely cohesive, despite Bálor being one of three challengers for Rollins’ WWE Intercontinental Championship at Greatest Royal Rumble.
The Riott Squad (Ruby Riott, Sarah Logan and Liv Morgan), Alexa Bliss and Mickie James defeated Nia Jax, Ember Moon, Natalya, Sasha Banks and Bayley
This match was pretty much exactly what you’d expect until Natalya sustained a leg ‘injury’. This took the ‘Queen of Harts’ out of the match and left her reeling at ringside. Following a Nia Jax leap off the apron onto almost all other competitors in the match, Mickie James viciously targeted Natalya’s ‘injured’ leg. This led to ‘Rowdy’ Ronda Rousey making her way down to the ring and attacking James herself, and thus the disqualification victory for James’ team.
Match of the Night
No match stood out as being particularly excellent, but in terms of serving its intended purpose, match of the night goes to Dolph Ziggler and Drew McIntyre’s win over Titus O’Neil and Apollo Crews.
SmackDown Live
The IIconics (Billie Kay and Peyton Royce) defeated Asuka and Becky Lynch
In their first match on the main roster as a team, the IIconics managed to defeat Asuka, who before WrestleMania 34 was undefeated for over 900 days. However, Royce did need a little assistance from the ropes to gain extra leverage on the pinfall, so I guess that’s alright? No. No, it’s not.
Jimmy Uso defeated Rowan
This looked like it was going to be another stroll in the park for one half of the Bludgeon Brothers. That was until Naomi made her entrance. For some reason, Harper and Rowan seemed utterly fascinated by the concept of glow in the dark ring attire, which allowed Uso to steal a roll-up win.
Shelton Benjamin defeated Randy Orton
Originally, this match was set to be Benjamin taking on Jeff Hardy in a rematch from last week, but much like the WWE United States Champion did to Orton last week, the ‘Viper’ strolled past Hardy and took on Benjamin instead. Hardy was sat at ringside, and during the match was attacked by Jinder Mahal’s accomplice, Sunil Singh. This distracted Orton, who hit Singh with an RKO, but allowed Benjamin to hit a Paydirt OUTTA NOWHERE, and claim the victory.
Shinsuke Nakamura, Rusev and Aiden English defeated AJ Styles, Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson
This was a fine match, but AJ Styles took far more offense than a WWE Champion should in my view. Eventually, he got the ‘hot tag’ to Luke Gallows, which came to no avail, and soon later the big man was hit with a Kinshasa to the back of the head, and Nakamura picked up the win, building momentum into his WWE Championship match against AJ Styles on Friday.
Match of the Night
Much like Raw, none of last night’s matches were head and shoulders above the rest, but in terms of again, serving its purpose, match of the night goes to Shelton Benjamin vs. Randy Orton.
The Verdict
Neither show really excelled in terms of in-ring action. There were a lot of roll-up wins and pretty much ‘copy and pastes’ of the same match – that being the underdog getting dominated and springing a surprise victory at the end.
I do have to say though, that SmackDown‘s ‘Match of the Night’ was a full-on competitive match, and not just a ‘squash match’ like Raw‘s, so the blue brand takes home the accolade of having the best in-ring action of the week.
‘Quality of Matches’ winner – SmackDown Live
Storyline Progression/Pay-Per-View Build
WWE is in a weird position, wherein they have the Greatest Royal Rumble this Friday, but also Backlash next Sunday, and trying to play the juggling act of promoting two shows at once, was evidently a pretty hard one.
Raw
Raw kicked off with Paul Heyman and Brock Lesnar promoting the ‘Beast’s Steel Cage clash with Roman Reigns at Greatest Royal Rumble. Heyman, as always delivered a cracking promo, but I hasten to say, he’s getting a little bit repetitive. This segment did nothing to ignite any interest within me in the WWE Universal Championship match on Friday.
Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn were drafted away from SmackDown Live to separate them from an authority figure storyline. Two weeks into their Raw tenure, and guess what they’re doing? You’re right, bickering with Kurt Angle. Hopefully, this isn’t a long-term thing, but I don’t have a good feeling. Angle putting Owens and Zayn in a match against Bobby Lashley and Braun Strowman just makes me feel sorry for the poor guys.
The only mention of Backlash on the entire show was a Samoa Joe selfie promo, during which he said he doesn’t even think he’ll have a match at Backlash because Brock Lesnar is going to destroy Roman Reigns so much. Joe is a cracking promo though and makes me believe everything he says, and his match against Reigns a week on Sunday is one I am looking forward to.
I assume this one isn’t building to a match at Backlash but No Way Jose looks to be Corbin’s first victim as he tries to climb the ranks on Monday nights. First, Corbin declined to have a match with Jose, and then attacked him from behind. Great heel-work, and as a fan of Corbin, this is a good way to kick off his Raw career.
The only other storyline that was really moved on during the three hours of Raw, was Ronda Rousey’s friendship with Natalya. As mentioned before, Rousey saved Nattie from a beat-down at the hands of Mickie James. I eventually expect Natalya to turn on Rousey, and the pair to have a match at some point in the not-too-distant future.
SmackDown Live
SmackDown kicked off with Miz TV. Daniel Bryan had prior been announced as The Miz’s guest, but instead, we got Big Cass. The seven-footer cut what I think was a great promo explaining why he’s a star, and Daniel Bryan isn’t. (Hint – it’s because he’s big). Before the next match, we saw Daniel Bryan in a heap after seemingly being attacked backstage, and this debacle was continued throughout the show.
The build to the Bludgeon Brothers’ WWE SmackDown Tag Team Championships defense at Greatest Royal Rumble has been fine, but given that we know Naomi won’t be in Jeddah, there’s not really any reason to get too excited.
We also had the contract signing between WWE SmackDown Women’s Champion Carmella and Charlotte Flair, for Charlotte’s rematch for the title at Backlash. To me, Carmella just came off as really irritating, which I assume was the goal, and Charlotte came off as a badass – not saying anything, just sitting stone-eyed and flipping tables, because it wouldn’t be a WWE contract signing without some form of vandalism, would it?
As mentioned earlier, the Shelton Benjamin-Randy Orton-Jeff Hardy triangle is continuing to progress, possibly to a triple-threat match for Hardy’s WWE United States Championship at some point. Fine stuff.
Renee Young interviewed Daniel Bryan on his attack earlier in the night, and Bryan confirmed that he will face Big Cass at Backlash. One more week to build to that match means one more week of Cass calling Bryan a “little man” probably. Either way, of course, we’re all excited to see Bryan’s first one-on-one pay-per-view match since his clearance.
The ending of the show, however, was the cream of the crop. Shinsuke Nakamura once again delivered a ‘low blow’ to AJ Styles. On top of that, the ‘Artist’ hit Karl Anderson with two Kinshasas right in front of Styles, and the WWE Champion could do nothing about it. Since Nakamura’s heel turn he has been absolutely fantastic and I am far more interested in their match this Friday than I was for their initial bout at WrestleMania 34.
The Verdict
SmackDown Live wins by an absolute landslide. They did a far better job of promoting Greatest Royal Rumble, and even the storylines that are going on on Raw, haven’t hooked my interest in the slightest.
‘Storyline Progression/Pay-per-view Build’ winner – SmackDown Live
Fun
What is ‘fun’? To have fun is to enjoy something. So in this section, we’re going to compare the most enjoyable things that happened on WWE TV this week. This could be in the form of comedy, it could be in the form excellent promos, or it could just be anything that put a smile on our faces.
Raw
Despite me previously saying that I’m not enjoying the conflict between Kurt Angle and Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn, that doesn’t mean these three men aren’t entertaining. The latter two men brought up a previous Kurt Angle mistake, in which he forgot that Jason Jordan was his son. This made me chuckle and rightfully so.
Something else that made me chuckle throughout Raw was the Miztourage’s attempts to convince Seth Rollins and Finn Bálor to take them on as protégés, much like The Miz did.
- Bo Dallas “Are you thinking what I’m thinking?”
- Curtis Axel “I actually have no idea what you’re thinking haha!”
- Absolute gold.
Jinder Mahal isn’t exactly renowned for being funny, but he was exactly that two nights ago. He pretended to get Chad Gable confused with the youngest champion in WWE history, Nicholas. A joke so unfunny, that it was absolutely hilarious.
I also really enjoyed Baron Corbin’s promo. Not because it was funny, just because it was a great promo.
SmackDown Live
The IIconics are fantastic. They have superb chemistry and they have the same sense of humor I referred to with Jinder Mahal earlier, they are not funny. Which makes them really, really funny. Their promo last night was a prime example of just that.
The Verdict
Although SmackDown Live bested Raw in the other areas, the red brand was far richer in terms of little moments that put a smile on my face and at the end of the day, that’s what it’s all about.
Overall
So which show was better this week? Our flawless, completely objective system suggests that SmackDown Live outdid Raw, and that is an assessment I completely agree with.
Winner – SmackDown Live
Which show do you think was best this week? Are there any flaws in our completely flawless system? Let us know in the comments below or on Twitter here, and as always, have a spiffing Rusev Day.









Comments.
Loading comments…