John Cena Legitimately Fractured Former WWE Star’s Elbow With A Receipt

Published: Nov 29, 2025 by Connel Rumsey | Last Updated: Nov 29, 2025 by Connel Rumsey

Connel has over five years of wrestling journalism experience writing about some of the biggest stories from across the wrestling world. Being a fan for 20 years, Connel has an expansive knowledge from a wide range of various wrestling promotions, including WWE, AEW, NJPW, TNA and Joshi.
@connel1405

John Cena legitimately fractured the elbow of a former WWE star after delivering a ‘receipt’ during their storyline.

Cena spent the Summer months of 2010 feuding with the Nexus faction on WWE television, including a big Elimination Tag Team match at SummerSlam which he ended up winning.

Following the show, the Nexus slowly begun losing members, with both Skip Sheffield and Michael Tarver suffering injuries.

Speaking in a new YouTube video, David Otunga recalled Cena hitting he and Tarver with a steel chair, which led to Cena legitimately fracturing Tarver’s elbow.

He said:

ADVERTISEMENT

“I vividly remember this. There was a spot where Tarver and I had to slide in the ring and Cena had a chair, and he was going to hit us with a chair.

“I’d only been in the business for little over a year, very green, this was my first time experiencing a chair shot. I just know ok, they’re gonna hit me in the back, open up for it. I did, opened up. Cena hit me with that chair, I’m telling you right now, that was one of the most painful things I felt inside a wrestling ring. I thought, wait a minute? That that can’t be right, that must have been a mistake. Then he did it again.

“Look, I was supposed to be in there for four or five shots. I took maybe one and a half and I was like, uh-uh, absolutely not. I rolled out of the ring. This is one of the only times I was I wasn’t taking something.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I realized it’s because Cena was doing this on purpose; he was trying to get his receipt. I had heard him mention something before about that and definitely after the fact, and he was letting it be known in the ring at the time! ‘This is for all those times you did this. This is for all the times you did that’, like he’s muttering under his breath.

“Boy, when I got away he was tearing Tarver up. He was tearing Tarver up. Tarver didn’t get out as quickly as I did, I think Tarver thought he was tough and tried to take it, but one of those shots showed how stiff it was, and actually fractured Tarver’s elbow. Like he legitimately was hurt.

“I know Tarver talked about this and people thought he was just complaining, or making it up, or exaggerating. No, that really happened. I was the other man in the ring with Tarver, I’m telling you, that really happened. I’m telling you, it was our receipts from Nexus because Cena actually told us that, and said something about that after the fact when we came to the back like ‘that was your receipt, you still got more coming’.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Alright John, but I tell you what, that was my first and last time getting hit by a chair by John Cena in WWE.”

If you use this transcription or any portion of it, please credit WrestleTalk.com and link to this page.

To make sure you stay up to date with all the biggest wrestling and WrestleTalk news, follow us on Threads by clicking this link!

Trending

Get the latest wrestling news straight to your inbox

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from WrestleTalk