Former WWE Writer Admits He Didn’t Understand Broken Matt Hardy

Former WWE Writer Admits He Didn’t Understand Broken Matt Hardy AEW

WWE Hall of Famer Road Dogg Brian James has admitted that he didn’t understand the appeal behind ‘Broken’ Matt Hardy.

Ahead of the Hardy Boyz return to WWE in April 2017, Matt Hardy had gained a lot of popularity wrestling with his ‘Broken’ gimmick.

There were attempts to revive this persona in WWE, with Matt introducing a ‘Woken’ gimmick, however the two characters, while similar, had key differences.

Speaking on the ‘Oh You Didn’t Know’ podcast, Road Dogg, who was working as a WWE writer from 2016 to 2019, shared his honest thoughts on Matt’s character:

“I didn’t get the Broken character. I never got it. I don’t understand it.

“If there’s something to understand, I would love to know what that is, but he just changed and talked differently. I don’t know. I didn’t see the transformation or follow it.

“I never got it. That was not me writing that. We put him with Bray because we thought together they could really be this cool entity, but I will say, no, we didn’t know what to do with them.

“The part I’m going to unpack is, what were their characters? If you could describe them to me, if you could give me an elevator pitch, a summary of their characters, then maybe we could have written them in that direction or something.

“I’ll take the heat and I always will for a failed opportunity, an opportunity I missed as a writer or a creative guy on the show. I’ll always take the hit for that.

“We let them be their creative selves and their creative selves, and this is horrible, and I don’t mean to say it like this, but I don’t think they knew at that time what they were trying to do.

“I don’t think they knew, I don’t think we knew, and together, it made a who knew stew, and so it turned out as such.

“I will take some heat for that, no two ways about it. I just don’t know if anybody else who should, will.”

Matt Hardy currently wrestles for AEW, most recently competing in 8-man tag-team action at the April 7 Dark taping.

Road Dogg currently serves as WWE’s Senior Vice President of Live Events.

Transcription via

If you want to stay fully updated on all the latest wrestling news, click the red bell in the bottom right of your screen to receive notifications from straight to your device!

1 year ago by Sanchez Taylor


Get the latest wrestling news straight to your inbox

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from WrestleTalk